Skip to main content

ACE Update 11.07.16: Classification Study Consultant Selected, Negotiations Update, New ACE Officers, Overtime vs. Comp Time

President’s Message


In the past month, ACE has held officer elections, selected a consultant for our classification study and opened negotiations with the District (more on these below), but what stands out the most to me is the increased level of participation from you, our members, at meetings and online through feedback and voting on the work ACE has done on your behalf. Thank you.

With the exception of my position, ACE is a volunteer run organization and the elected officers serve in addition to their full-time FHDA job.   We serve with the belief that collectively we are stronger together on issues affecting our pay, our benefits, and our working conditions. Throughout the years this has meant COLA’s typically 1% or greater than what the State has offered, comprehensive and affordable health benefits in spite of rising costs, Professional Growth Awards adding to your earning potential, Staff Development Leaves at 85% of your pay, funds to cover travel and conference, educational assistance and more.  Often these benefits are born out of ideas and issues at a specific point in time, morphing and changing as budgets and circumstances allow, but our guiding principle has always been to act in the best interest of our members, even if at times our actions feel antiquated or unfair. It is my hope that you keep this in mind as we move forward.

As we begin this classification study, now more than ever, your participation is crucial in developing a classification system that works for all ACE members.  With this new study, our goal is to develop a clear, equitable, consistent and competitive classification and compensation structure that appeals to and fosters retention of qualified classified staff professionals while providing opportunities for growth and development throughout the district.  Consistent and ongoing communication will be essential during this study, and we will do our best to keep you informed, but we need you to read, ask questions, attend meetings, and ultimately, vote if we are going to be successful.

Of Service,

Chris White, ACE President
(650) 949-7789, office


Classification Study Consultant Selected

 By Chris White, President

After many hours of negotiations, interviewing and checking references, Koff & Associates have been selected to work with us on a classification study.   The contract begins Jan. 1, 2017 and runs through Dec. 31, 2017.   Barring delays, the study is expected to take between 6-9 months to complete.

After speaking with several labor representatives at other community colleges who were a part of classification studies administered by Koff & Associates, ACE, by way of the Joint Labor Management Classification Committee (JLMCC), selected this agency and is confident that they are the best consultant for our study.  The factors that informed this selection include:

  1. They prioritize a collaborative process with HR and the Union throughout the entire process;
  2. Their job descriptions were more detailed and more concise, making it easier to identify career ladders and when a classified staff employee is working out of class; and
  3. They have a strong background working with colleges of similar size in the public sector and higher education.

As part of an MOU that ACE signed with the District on Oct. 13, 2016, we agreed:

  1. At this time, the District will fund the full cost of the study. If additional funds are needed beyond the contracted agreement with Koff, we will renegotiate possible use of ACE funds that were approved by ACE members in September 2016;
  2. ACE and the District have joint authority over the study and implementation through the JLMCC;
  3. Regardless of the outcome, no District employee will have his or her salary reduced; and
  4. Effective Oct. 21, 2016, reclassifications currently under review will be completed but no new reclassifications will be allowed. Why?  Because ACE and HR require staff time and resources to prepare for the studies launch. Additionally, there isn’t enough time in the reclassification process, which includes appeals, to get a new one completed before the study is scheduled to begin.

Why are we conducting this study? The last time FHDA conducted a classification study was nearly 20 years ago.  As you can imagine, the roles and responsibilities of employees, required skill sets, and working conditions and environments have radically changed, thanks in part to technological and organizational advances since that last study in 1998.

What is the purpose of the study? The goal is to align job descriptions with the current roles and responsibilities of classified employees, develop career ladders where appropriate, and conduct a market analysis of compensation in similar or like jobs in other districts.

Our members have the final say. It is important for Koff & Associates, the District, and ACE to work collaboratively on this study. If our members do not approve of the final recommendations, they will not be implemented.


New ACE Officers
Congratulations to your newly elected ACE Officers, who serve in addition to their 40-hour a week FHDA jobs. Their term runs Jan. 1, 2017 – Dec. 31, 2018.

Treasurer:                               Annette Perez
CS Chief Steward:                  Irma Rodarte
CS Board Member:                 Scott Olsen
DA Chief Steward:                  Paula Joseph
DA Board Member, Seat 2:    Selda Sigala-Aguilar
FH Vice President:  
                Denise Perez


Negotiations Update

By Chris Dubeau, Chair of Negotiations

For 2016-2017, pursuant to Article 20.5 of the ACE Agreement, ACE opened the following:

  • Article 8: Pay and Allowances
  • Article 9: Holidays and Vacation
  • Article 14: Worker Expenses and Materials
  • Article 18: Benefits

We are still waiting to see which two articles, if any, the District would like to open.

With the COLA already negotiated, under Article 8 we also hope to address some of the inequity in earning potential for ACE members our current Professional Growth Award (PGA) system has developed over the years.

Under Article 9, where two-thirds of our members agreed in our negotiations survey, we would like to move the Cesar Chavez holiday, currently observed in early September, to a date closer to the actual holiday on March 31. We would also like to address the number of holiday hours members are credited if they are required to work a 40-hour a week schedule other than the standard five-day, 8-hours a day workweek.

Under Article 14, ACE is looking to increase the amount that members can receive for educational reimbursement as well as travel and conference.  Currently, these amounts are set at $1000 and $1500 annually.

With no increase to employee health benefit contribution rates for the 2017 plan year already negotiated, under Article 18, ACE is reviewing opportunities to address the benefit amount of the Bridge to Medicare Program.  Currently, set at a reimbursement rate of 2.8% (5.6% for employee +1) on the salary schedule for our bargaining unit, the payout rate for administrators is nearly double that which ACE members would receive even though we all pay the same rates for our health care benefits.

The biggest question mark for most of these items is the budget for FHDA as well as the State’s.  FHDA estimates a $6 million deficit for this year due to declining enrollment. The state budget looks relatively stable but has the potential to be bolstered with the passing of Prop 55. We will have a better idea on what, if any, additional funding the State will offer in the governor’s initial budget proposal in late January.  Until then, we wait.


Overtime vs. Comp Time

By Anthony Booth, Labor Consultant
Law Office of Bradley G. Booth

Quick history review: In 1938, the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) became law. It established the 40-hour work week by mandating that for any hours worked past 40, employers are legally required to pay time-and-a-half to employees who work these hours. The law further requires that employees are to receive their overtime pay in their next pay period. The goal of time-and-a-half pay is to give employers a financial incentive to hire more workers when they have more work and to ensure employees were given extra compensation for those hours worked beyond 40 in a week. California has also stated that any hours worked over 8 hours a day is compensable overtime at time and a half, except when you work an authorize alternative work schedule, then it’s those hours beyond your regular schedule.

The California Education Code authorizes compensatory time off for classified workers at community colleges. (See section 88027) It further states that when compensatory time off is authorized in lieu of cash such time off shall be granted within 12 calendar months following the month in which the overtime was worked. (Section 88028). These laws have been included in the ACE Agreement.

Article 13.2 of the ACE Agreement discusses overtime and comp time requirements including what determines overtime and payout rates.  Beyond those, it is important to note:

  • Any overtime, whether you get paid or take comp time, must be approved, preferably in writing, by your supervisor prior to the hours being worked;
  • The choice to receive pay or comp time is strictly up to the employee. You may choose, but cannot be forced to take comp time in place of overtime pay.  Comp time makes overtime work cheaper for the employer, so they will be more likely to schedule it, because the additional work gets done and takes away the primary incentive to hire more people; and
  • Comp time must be used within 12-calendar months following the month in which it was reported on the time report.  If it is not used within this period the worker will be paid for the comp hours accrued at the overtime rate that was effective for the worker when the overtime was worked

Any employee who has worked more than 8 hours in a day, unless on an alternative work schedule, or more than 40 hours in a week and their supervisor knows or should know they did the work, and hasn’t been paid for the overtime, should keep track of the hours worked and contact a Union representative.

ACE Update 10.6.16: Negotiations, Classification Study, PAC

President’s Message


When I ran for this office I shared with you that I had two primary objectives:

  • Strengthen our ACE Agreement and
  • Strengthen the unity of our membership.

Both will always be works in progress, but I feel good about some of the things that ACE has accomplished in the past nine months.  These include giving members first chance to apply for open positions before outside candidates, and permanently reducing member dues.

I don’t feel quite as good that members have been affected by a silence in our Agreement. Some feel unheard about challenging work environments. Some are bothered by the fact that managers–right or wrong– have the right of assignment and that ACE doesn’t have authority to affect a different outcome.  So, I do the only thing I know how to do:  Look for opportunities for change.  To that end, below are some of the ideas and goals that ACE is pursuing–all with the goal of bringing about meaningful change to our workplace:

  • Classification study.  The last time that FHDA conducted a classification study, the price of gas was $1.06 a gallon, a loaf of bread cost $1.26, and many of our new members were in high school.   As you can imagine, the roles and responsibilities of employees, required skill sets, and working conditions and environments have radically changed, thanks in part to technological and organizational advances since that last study in 1998. With this new study, our goal is to develop a clear, equitable, consistent and competitive classification and compensation structure that appeals to and fosters retention of qualified classified staff professionals while providing opportunities for growth and development throughout the district.  Your approval for the use of ACE funds to pay for a portion of the survey, if necessary, ensures that we have joint authority with the district to determine how this study will be conducted and implemented. We’re still negotiating these terms, and having some financial leverage helps. To keep the process moving forward, we have jointly interviewed four classification consultants and are in the process of conducting reference checks. Once we finalize the terms of the study, we can choose a consultant. We will keep you informed as the process progresses.
  • Strengthening classified positions. Along with the classification study, ACE will be reviewing the use of temporary and student employees to see if there are opportunities to create classified staff positions in their place. Earlier this year, we were successful in converting several classified hourly positions into four permanent positions–which now include guaranteed hours and affordable benefits–after a member alerted ACE to a high percentage of district-funded student employees doing the same work as classified staff professionals.  While there are legitimate uses by the district for temporary and student workers, the sheer number of these temporary positions requires comprehensive review.
  • Have honest conversations.  We’ve heard the concerns from members regarding retributive and bullying supervisors, heavy workloads from staffing cuts made several years ago, and a lack of job mobility. To address the first issue, we’ve created a Mutual Respect Complaint form to help establish a record of conduct by supervisors when no violation of the Agreement has occurred and use them in our conversations with the district regarding this issue.  We’ve addressed the last issue with our new voluntary transfer process, which gives internal applicants a chance to interview for a lateral position before it is opened to external candidates. It’s not a perfect process, and we’re committed to refining it, but it is a start. ACE has also been holding conversations with the district’s board of trustees, chancellor, and human resources managers regarding accountability for behavior and how it needs to be addressed at all levels, even if there is no direct violation of our Agreement. The more instances we can present in writing through our Mutual Respect Complaint form, the more difficult it becomes for the district to ignore them. Employee dissatisfaction and high turnover have a direct impact on student success, equity, and enrollment and in today’s climate FHDA can’t afford to lose ground in any of those areas.

You can help.

  • Get involved. Officer elections are this month.  We also have an opening for a negotiator from De Anza. Not your style? Attend a site meeting or send a representative. For DA, meetings are generally held the first Tuesday of the month at noon in Admin 109. For FH/CS, meetings are generally held the third Tuesday of the month at noon in the Toyon Room.  We’ll be serving pizza.
  • Vote.  Throughout the year, ACE will send you surveys to get your feedback.  It’s your feedback that guides your ACE team at the bargaining table.
  • Give feedback, offer solutions. Other than myself, all of the ACE’s officers do this work in addition to their full-time FHDA jobs.  None of us thinks that we have all the answers but we will work with you to find answers to your questions.
  • Speak up. If you are constantly denied vacation because you’re the only one who does your work and your supervisor is concerned how the work will get done without you, tell us. We will work with you and your supervisor to come up with a solution but we can’t help you if we don’t know about it.
  • Be patient.  As my friend and FH Chief Steward Art Hand likes to remind me, everything will always take longer than you think.

As your ACE president, it’s my pleasure to speak with you about any of your concerns and answer any questions you have about your union and the Agreement.  Call or e-mail me anytime.

Sincerely,

Chris White, ACE President
(650) 949-7789, office


ACE Officer Elections

Elections for the following ACE positions will take place in October.

  • Treasurer
  • Vice President, Foothill
  • Chief Steward, De Anza & Central Services
  • Board Member, DA/Seat 2 & Central Services
See Article 5 of the ACE Constitution for job descriptions.

Nomination/General Membership Mtg

Oct. 11, DA Admin 109
Oct. 18, FH/CS Toyon Rm. (2020)

For any contested positions, elections will be held online Oct. 31 – Nov. 4.


Negotiations Update

By Chris Dubeau, Chair of Negotiations

Negotiations Survey
Thank you to everyone who responded to our negotiations survey.  With a 30-percent response rate, you told us your top priorities included classification, holidays and vacations, and temporary work.  We are working to address two of those issues outside of negotiations.

  • Classification and reclassification through a comprehensive study to be conducted by a hired third-party agency within the academic year.
  • Temporary work will most likely be addressed legally.  ACE is now collecting the information we need to develop a clear process for such work.

With the COLA already negotiated (0.6 beginning July 1, 2016), and based on your survey feedback, we’re reviewing holidays and vacations, as well as some additional areas which could affect your pay, like equity for Professional Growth Awards (PGAs) and longevity awards.

Remember that ACE may only open two contract articles in this year’s negotiations cycle. This means that ACE members and leadership must make choices like those you have identified in the recent negotiations survey. Keep in mind the district operates from a you-have-to-give-something-to-get-something stance.

Health Benefits and the VEBA
Last year, ACE also negotiated no increase to health benefits for the 2017 plan year. For this year, through the Joint Labor Management Benefits Council (JLMBC), ACE will address a more equitable distribution of the Bridge to Medicare program in addition to employee health care benefit rates for the 2018 plan year.  The Voluntary Employee Benefit Association (VEBA) is set to distribute funds to post-1997 Medicare-eligible retirees at a rate of $100 per month.  The premium reimbursement is retroactive to January 1, 2016, and the district will notify those that are eligible. An application was agreed upon with minor adjustments and will be distributed as soon as modifications are completed and approved by the VEBA board of trustees.


Negotiator Needed

Representing De Anza:

  • You must be a permanent, full-dues-paying member.
  • The time commitment is typically less than 2 hours every few weeks during active negotiations.
  • Release time is available and we will work with you and your supervisor to get this arranged.
Contact Chris Dubeau, Chair of Negotiations, for more information.

ACE Political Action Committee (PAC)
By Chris White, ACE President

What is the PAC?
Established in 2010, the Political Action Committee (PAC) is a subcommittee of the ACE Executive Board. Reliant solely on voluntary donations contributed by members, the PAC works to support political action which directly relates to FHDA, such as property tax proposals, FHDA Board of Trustee elections or statewide initiatives affecting community colleges.

PAC History
When the PAC was established ACE–with member approval–loaned the PAC fund $10,000 to support FHDA’s parcel tax initiative with the hope of offsetting crippling budget cuts coming from the state.  Approval to fund the PAC was heavily favored by the membership.  However, the voluntary contributions to reimburse ACE for the loan have not been as robust. To date, the PAC fund still owes $3,000 to ACE.

Why is the ACE PAC important?
In this age of “political campaigns through the media,” the reputation of an organization is no longer enough to have meaningful, effective influence on legislative matters. The ACE PAC will strengthen our voice with FHDA Board ofTrustess, local and statewide elected officials. In the upcoming November election, there are three FHDA Trustee seats up for election and six candidates running for those seats; only one candidate is an incumbent. Those elected to our district’s board of trustees are responsible for budget and policy decisions which directly affect the classified staff of FHDA.

Why should you contribute to ACE PAC?
When you donate to ACE PAC, you’re sending a clear message to the FHDA Board of Trustees and local and state elected officials that classified staff issues are important to our profession, to the wider community college collective and to public interest sectors.  That clear message? We will be heard on matters that affect our careers and our families.

How can I contribute?
You can make a one-time donation or a monthly, ongoing contribution for any amount that works for your budget. Complete the ACE PAC Deduction Form and return it to the ACE office (Room D140 which is located adjacent to Lot 1-D at the Foothill campus). You can also contribute your time and talent to political causes and campaigns that are important to you and your classified colleagues.


What ACE Can Do For You

By Anthony Booth, Labor Consultant
Law Office of Bradley G. Booth

ACE supports its members with issues based on the Agreement between ACE and Foothill – De Anza Community College District.  No other document directly affects your role and paycheck in the district as much as the Agreement. You’ll find it online at acefhda.org. Bookmark it now, read it, ask ACE leaders questions if you need clarification on any of its content.

ACE represents its members in:

  • Disciplinary action issues to assure that the agreed-upon process detailed in the Agreement has been followed properly. Often, these issues can be easily resolved with further examination of the contract; and
  • Violations of the labor code or education code such as your supervisor assigning you to work overtime and then refusing to give you a choice between collecting overtime pay or accruing compensatory time for extra hours worked.  In this example, the choice is yours–not your supervisor’s.

There is no formal mechanism to resolve non-contractual disputes, such as your supervisor behaving unreasonably. ACE is willing to consult and mediate these situations, but the district is under no obligation to do so.

If you believe that a violation of the Agreement has occurred or want answers to your questions, call or e-mail your volunteer ACE stewards.

Central Services: Irma Rodarte, rodarteirma@fhda.edu • x6249
De Anza: Paula Joseph, josephpaula@fhda.edu • x8758
Foothill: Art Hand,  handart@fhda.edu • x7029

Be aware, ACE does not represent its members in discrimination cases, workers’ compensation claims or disputes between FHDA classified staff employees.

  • Discrimination cases: These are to be handled by the Department of Fair Employment and Housing (DFEH) [http://www.dfeh.ca.gov]  and the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) [https://www.eeoc.gov]
  • Workers’ Compensation Claims: We recommend that ACE members consult, at their own expense, Kathleen Storm of the Mastagni Law Firm at  (916) 446-4692; and
  • Disputes Between Classified Staff: ACE maintains a responsibility to represent all ACE members.  It is the responsibility of your supervisor and/or the district’s human resources office to address these disputes.

General Membership Meeting, 9/22: Dues Reduction & Classification Study

Dear ACE Members:

Please join ACE on District Opening Day (9/22) at 1 p.m. in the De Anza Campus Center, conference room B for a general membership meeting and ice cream social. We would like to review two items which require a vote by the membership:

  • A permanent 10% reduction in ACE monthly dues. Under the current ACE Constitution, Article 3.4.a, ACE membership dues are 1.05 % of the member’s base pay. A yes vote on this item would permanently reduce them to .95% of a member’s base pay.
  • We are asking for membership approval to use ACE funds to pay for half (1/2), not-to-exceed $100,000, the cost of a classification study for all job classifications within the ACE bargaining unit only.

Voting will take place online and opens Thursday, Sept. 22 at 3 p.m. and closes on Tuesday, Sept. 27 at noon.

In addition, we will also discuss:

  • Negotiations Update
  • Classification Study
  • Upcoming ACE officer elections
  • ACE Political Action Committee (PAC) Fund

Please be let us know if you’ll be attending so we can save you some ice cream.

Hope to see you there,
Chris White President, ACE